Menu

          ESPN

          • scores
          • NFL
          • NBA
          • MLB
          • NHL
          • Soccer
          • WNBA
          • Golf
          • More Sports
            • Boxing
            • NCAA
            • Cricket
            • F1
            • Gaming
            • Horse
            • LLWS
            • MMA
            • NASCAR
            • NLL
            • NBA G League
            • NBA Summer League
            • NCAAF
            • NCAAM
            • NCAAW
            • NWSL
            • Olympics
            • PLL
            • Racing
            • RN BB
            • RN FB
            • Rugby
            • Bananas
            • Sports Betting
            • Tennis
            • TGL
            • UFL
            • WWE
            • Professional Wrestling
          • Editions
          • Where to Watch
          • Fantasy
          • Watch
          • Rugby

          • Home
          • Scores
          • Tables
          • Tournaments
          • Countries
          Six Nations 2005
          ScotlandScotlandSCO
          13
          12/02FT
          40
          IrelandIrelandIRE
          • SummarySummary
          • ReportReport
          • LineupsLineups
          • TableTable

          Ireland thrash Scots at Murrayfield

          Ireland winger Denis Hickie dives in to score against Scotland at Murrayfield, February 12 2005 Getty Images
          • ESPN Staff
          Multiple Authors
          Feb 12, 2005, 03:00 AM ET
          • Copy Link
          • Email
          • Print


          Six Nations title favourites Ireland left Scotland all at sea at Murrayfield this evening, as octopus-armed locks Malcolm O'Kelly and Paul O'Connell were amongst the scorers in their five-try 40-13 triumph.

          O'Kelly's 24th-minute effort - marking his record-breaking 70th Test appearance in style - was the catalyst for Eddie O'Sullivan's side, who played in fits-and-starts, after converted centre Hugo Southwell's early breakaway try had promised so much for the Scots.

          In the opening 20 minutes, the home side seized control of possession and territory in a performance similar to last weekend's heroics in Paris - however this time they looked to have the points to pick off coach Matt Williams' first Championship success.

          O'Kelly ensured his former Leinster boss was soon in arrears, and after O'Connell's barge over effort before the break, and further touch downs from Denis Hickie, John Hayes and Gavin Duffy - earning his second Test cap - the sizeable traveling support were left wondering 'Brian and Gordon who?'

          Still it was Scotland who looked liked the Grand Slam challengers in the opening quarter. A Jason White incision set up full back Chris Paterson for the first points - a 20-metre penalty on 9 minutes.

          Edinburgh kicker Paterson then set up the Scots' first try - arguably the best one of the match. His searing midfield break past Reggie Corrigan and Peter Stringer gave Andy Craig the chance to send Southwell scuttling in at the right corner, evading the grasp of Shane Horgan in tow.

          It went sour thereafter for Williams' men as Paterson fluffed the conversion and Dan Parks sailed a drop goal attempt wide. O'Gara's first kick at the sticks produced a penalty in reply and O'Kelly handed the visitors a lead they failed to relinquish.

          The 30-year-old burrowed his 6ft 8in frame over in a close-range ruck and with Ireland 10-8 to the good, on the footing of O'Gara's pinpoint conversion, skipper-for-the-day O'Connell plunged through the weak tackles of Parks and Gavin Kerr to gift the Irish a ten-point buffer at the break.

          Without ever hitting top gear, O'Sullivan's men seemed to ease away, and with Scottish scrum half Chris Cusiter getting no change from his own forwards, Hickie was allotted the chance to draw within one of Ireland's record try scorer Brian O'Driscoll three minutes after the restart.

          A quick snaffle of the ball from flanker Johnny O'Connor was shipped onto O'Gara and he fed the Leinster winger, who made the left corner with ease.

          Exhibiting much more control, especially in the loose, O'Gara hammered through the conversion. Scotland showed signs of a revival just before the hour as 26-year-old Paterson was again the gain-line breaker.

          His effort won a lineout and with Stuart Grimes pocketing the throw, openside Jon Petrie was rumbled over at the side of the ruck.

          Two more tries from the Irish in the final eight minutes saw off that dawn as first, tighthead prop Hayes was the unlikely recipient of a right wing ball from O'Kelly, and he had enough power to beat substitute Mike Blair for the touchdown.

          Duffy's injury time skip over - profiting from turnover ball - handed O'Sullivan a fifth straight win over Scotland in his fortieth game in charge - and a positive outlook heading into the Lansdowne Road cruncher with England in two weeks' time.

          Scotland: 13 Try: Southwell, Petrie Pen: Paterson

          Ireland: 40 Try: OÂŽKelly, OÂŽConnell, Hickie, Hayes, Duffy Con: OÂŽGara (2), Humphreys Pen: OÂŽGara (3)

          Scotland:

          SCOTLAND: Chris Paterson; Simon Danielli, Andy Craig, Hugo Southwell, Sean Lamont; Dan Parks, Chris Cusiter, Tom Smith, Gordon Bulloch (Capt), Gavin Kerr, Stuart Grimes, Scott Murray, Jason White, Jon Petrie, Allister Hogg.

          Replacements: Robbie Russell, Bruce Douglas, Nathan Hines, Jon Dunbar, Mike Blair, Gordon Ross, Ben Hinshelwood.

          Subs used: Mike Blair for Cusiter (6-16 mins), Bruce Douglas for Kerr, Nathan Hines for Murray, Blair for Cusiter (all 70)

          IRELAND: Geordan Murphy; Girvan Dempsey, Shane Horgan, Kevin Maggs, Denis Hickie; Ronan OÂŽGara, Peter Stringer; Reggie Corrigan, Shane Byrne, John Hayes, Malcolm OÂŽKelly, Paul OÂŽConnell (Capt), Simon Easterby, Johnny OÂŽConnor, Anthony Foley.

          Replacements: Frankie Sheahan, Marcus Horan, Donncha OÂŽCallaghan, Eric Miller, Guy Easterby, David Humphreys, Gavin Duffy.

          Subs used: Eric Miller for OÂŽConnor (66 mins), Frankie Sheahan for Byrne, Marcus Horan for Corrigan (both 71), Guy Easterby for Stringer, Donncha OÂŽCallaghan for OÂŽKelly, David Humphreys for OÂŽGara, Gavin Duffy for Hickie (all 75)

          HT: Scotland 8 Ireland 18; Attendance: 67,800 Referee: Joel Jutge (France)

          • Terms of Use
          • Privacy Policy
          • Your US State Privacy Rights
          • Children's Online Privacy Policy
          • Interest-Based Ads
          • About Nielsen Measurement
          • Your Privacy Choices
          • Contact Us
          • Disney Ad Sales Site
          • Work for ESPN
          • Corrections
          GAMBLING PROBLEM? CALL 1-800-GAMBLER, (800) 327-5050 or visit gamblinghelplinema.org (MA). Call 877-8-HOPENY/text HOPENY (467369) (NY). Please Gamble Responsibly. 888-789-7777/visit ccpg.org (CT), or visit www.mdgamblinghelp.org (MD). 21+ and present in most states. (18+ DC/KY/NH/WY). Void in ONT/OR/NH. Eligibility restrictions apply. On behalf of Boot Hill Casino & Resort (KS). Terms: sportsbook.draftkings.com/promos.
          Copyright: © 2026 ESPN Enterprises, LLC. All rights reserved.

          Standings

          Six Nations
          RTeamGPPDP
          1FRA5+8121
          2IRE5+3819
          3SCO5-116
          4ITA5-389
          5ENG5+28
          6WAL5-826
          Full Table

          Six Nations 2005 News

          • Women's Six Nations 2026: How to watch, schedule, results, table, squads, news, TV channel

            Everything you need to know about the 2026 Women's Six Nations.

          • France 28-43 England: Red Roses clinch eighth-straight Women's Six Nations crown

            England clinched a fifth successive Grand Slam as Ellie Kildunne and Jess Breach ran in two tries each in a 43-28 triumph over France in Bordeaux.

          • France vs. England, Women's Six Nations: How to watch, kick-off time, TV channel, team news

            Everything you need to know ahead of the Women's Six Nations Grand Slam decider between France and England.

          • Italy 33-61 England, Women's Six Nations: Marlie Packer scores four as Red Roses dominate

            England are on track for another Women's Six Nations Grand Slam after a 33-61 win over Italy in Parma thanks to four tries from Marlie Packer.

          • Wales rugby great Leigh Halfpenny announces retirement

            Wales great Leigh Halfpenny will retire at the end of the season to bring down the curtain on a professional career spanning almost two decades.

          • RFU backs England head coach Steve Borthwick after review

            The RFU has backed England men's head coach Steve Borthwick after undertaking a "detailed and robust review" of their dismal Six Nations campaign.